Skip to main content

Why Didn't Lehigh Host? And Other FCS Playoff Thoughts

By now you probably know that Lehigh is headed to New Hampshire on Saturday to face off against the Wildcats in the first round of the FCS Playoffs.

About this, some of you are scratching your heads.  Lehigh is 9-2, you say.  Every single computer rating system has them ranked ahead of New Hampshire, every single human voter poll has them ranked against New Hampshire.  Lehigh won the Patriot League outright; New Hampshire weren't even co-champions of the CAA.  Why is New Hampshire hosting us?

The answer resides in the bidding process and some NCAA rules, both of which explain why it happened.

I'll talk about this, and my other thoughts on the bracket, below.

Let's start with the structure of the FCS playoffs.

The field is constructed in several stages.

First, the autobids are determined.  Ten conferences have their champions (or co-champions) qualify automatically for the FCS playoffs.  The Patriot League is one, and their autobid went to Lehigh.

Next, fourteen at-large teams are picked from the remaining teams that aren't autobids.  One of these teams, interestingly, was North Dakota State, who were co-champions of the Missouri Valley but didn't get the autobid thanks to their head-to-head loss to South Dakota State.

Only after the entire field is selected are the seeds, 1-8, determined from the entire pool of teams.

The fact that things are done in exact order explains some things that, taken alone, do not make sense.  10-1 North Dakota State technically did not win the autobid from the Missouri Valley, however, when they line up all the teams in a row, they could still determine that North Dakota State should be the No. 1 overall seed (which is what happened in this field).

I think the biggest misconception in the FCS playoff field is that the results of one step inform the other.  They don't necessarily, and as you will see, this is why Lehigh is on the road in their first round game.

So once the seeds 1 through 8 have been determined, the remaining teams are grouped together regionally wherever appropriate.  Of note: the remaining seeds are not seeded from 9 to 24, and matched to play one another.

The reason for this is to keep the costs down for staging the championship, something that the NCAA reimburses.

To understand why, let's hypothetically say, if you seeded the entire field, Lehigh happened to be slated to play at Weber State.  Lehigh would be required to fly out to Utah to play their game.  Let's also say Villanova was slated to play San Diego, based on the full seeding, and the Toreros would need to fly to Philadelphia for their game.

Does that make sense when you could schedule Lehigh at Villanova, and San Diego at Weber State instead?  Few Lehigh alums are going to be able to schedule a flight to Utah during Thanksgiving weekend, but many would be able to set aside an afternoon on a Saturday holiday weekend that's a quick drive from Bethlehem.

Furthermore, for the athletes themselves, it's a major win.  They can practice at home, and can take a bus to the game rather than flying across country, across time zones, at an unfamiliar location on a week's notice.  In basketball, it's not a big deal to practice in a high school gym, but for football, it's an entirely different proposition.

So now you know the process: 1) Lehigh made the field; 2) the rest of the at-large teams were chosen; 3) the seeds were chosen, and 4) the first-round matchups were determined with some regionality in mind.  Now, we enter stage 5) who hosts.

Host team in a playoff game is commonly assumed to be completely financial.  However... there is much more to the criteria than simple dollars.
When determining host institutions for playoff games when both teams are unseeded, criteria shall apply as follows: (1) quality of facility, (2) revenue potential plus estimated net receipts, (3) attendance history and potential, (4) team’s performance (i.e., conference place finish, head-to-head results and number of Division I opponents), and (5) student-athlete well-being (e.g., travel and missed class time).
(You'll note "loudest Twitter followers", sadly, are not listed among the criteria, much to my disappointment.)

"The Dungeon"
In Lehigh's case, there is indeed a blind bid that Lehigh submitted several weeks ago that showed Lehigh's "seriousness" to host a game.  However, as you can see from the official handbook, concepts like "quality of facility", "revenue potential" and "attendance history" are big factors - not size of guarantee.

As Spike over at The Sports Arsenal shows, New Hampshire's average attendance for games this season was 11,108 vs. Lehigh's 6,527.  If the committee simply decided on "revenue potential/net receipts" or "attendance history" for hosting in this particular case, New Hampshire wins that argument fairly convincingly.

There's also the matter of "quality of facility".  A "quality" facility is certainly subjective (certainly I think Murray Goodman is second to none in terms of beauty and a great place to watch a game), but in the specific case of a college football game in late November, "quality" might mean the ability to host a game that could be a night game.  UNH's Dungeon has the ability to host a game starting at 2PM, simply because they have lights.  Lehigh does not have anything permanent in place to allow them to do so.

I think when you show this evidence, it shows that the way the rules are set up, Lehigh will always lose a bidding war in a 1st round game vs. a school like UNH.  Lehigh wouldn't necessary lose to every team they could theoretically be bidding against, but they'd lose to a lot of them, based on those cold, hard numbers.

And it also shows that there are only three ways to bridge that gap for the future:

  • Be good enough to be seeded 1-8 (because you are guaranteed the chance to host)
  • Get more people to come to the games (because "revenue potential" and "attendance history" are a key part of the calculus)
  • Either install permanent lights at Murray Goodman or have a convincing plan to be able to light Murray Goodman and its parking areas with temporary lighting (because then "quality of facility" becomes a wash).
It's easy to complain about the process.  It's harder to do the little things required - and that means fans as much as administrators - in order to play the game in the way that the NCAA wants.  Lehigh can do things, I think, on all three fronts to make it more likely in the future to see home games at Murray Goodman.  It's up to all of us to make it happen.


I have some other thoughts about the bracket too.  I'll just list these as bullet points.
  • Frankly, I'm a bit sad that Fordham didn't make the field with an 8-3 record.  In my final bracket prediction, I picked 23 out of the 24 teams, and had Fordham in as the last team instead of 7-4 Weber State.  
  • There was a good reason for that, too: I had Villanova as the 8 seed over North Dakota, which would have opened up the possibility of another Eastern team, or so I thought.  I thought that the committee would value having an extra Eastern team simply due to cost-containment reasons.
  • The reason I picked this was that I forgot my own rule, which I stated above: the input from one step (picking all the teams) doesn't bleed into the other steps (picking an Eastern seeded team, picking regional matchups).  
  • But if they had, however, done exactly as I said, which was seed an Eastern team at No. 7 or No. 8, and then let that be a factor in the picking of the last team, they could have avoided not just one unnecessary plane flight, but potentially a bunch.
  • As the bracket stands now, Weber State flies out to Chattanooga for a 1st round game, and Samford flies up to Youngstown State.  
  • Had they had Richmond host Fordham (bus trip) and had the winner head to Villanova (bus trip), that would have opened up lots more bus savings, like, for example a possible North Dakota/Illinois State 1st round game (flight) with the winner playing North Dakota State 2nd round matchup (bus trip), Chattanooga/North Carolina A&T (bus trip), and Youngstown State/St. Francis (PA) (bus trip).  
  • I don't believe any of the above matchups are serious competitive compromises from what the actual bracket ended up becoming, and with the exception of Illinois State/North Dakota (which would require a flight for whomever is slated to play there) they're all bus trips. 
  •  Instead, though, five of the eight second-round games as they stand right now are going to require a flight (and if Youngstown State defeats Samford at home this Saturday, the number will be six).  Whether they realize it or not, the NCAA added a lot of extra cost to this tournament in the later rounds, and it will reflect that when they look at the bottom line after the playoffs are over.  Much of that could have been avoided, in my opinion.


Popular posts from this blog

How The Ivy League Is Able To Break the NCAA's Scholarship Limits and Still Consider Themselves FCS

By now you've seen the results.  In 2018, the Ivy League has taken the FCS by storm. Perhaps it was Penn's 30-10 defeat of Lehigh a couple of weeks ago .  Or maybe it was Princeton's 50-9 drubbing of another team that made the FCS Playoffs last year, Monmouth.  Or maybe it was Yale's shockingly dominant 35-14 win over nationally-ranked Maine last weekend. The Ivy League has gone an astounding 12-4 so far in out-of-conference play, many of those wins coming against the Patriot League. But it's not just against the Patriot League where the Ivy League has excelled.  Every Ivy League school has at least one out-of-conference victory, which is remarkable since it is only three games into their football season.  The four losses - Rhode Island over Harvard, Holy Cross over Yale, Delaware over Cornell, and Cal Poly over Brown - were either close losses that could have gone either way or expected blowouts of teams picked to be at the bottom of the Ivy League. W

UMass 21, Lafayette 14, halftime

Are you watching this game? UMass had this game under control until about 3 minutes in the second quarter, and then got an interception, converted for a TD. Then the Leopards forced a fumble off the return, and then converted THAT for a TD, making this a game. It's on CN8. You really should be watching this.

Made-Up Midseason Grades for Lehigh Football

 We are now officially midway through the 2023 Lehigh football season.  The Mountain Hawks sit at 1-5 overall, and 0-1 in the Patriot League. I thought I'd go ahead and make up some midseason grades, and set some "fan goals" for the second half. The 2023 Mountain Hawks were picked to finish fifth in the seven team Patriot League.  In order to meet or exceed that expectation, they'll probably have to go at least 3-2 the rest of the way in conference play.  Their remaining games are vs. Georgetown, at Bucknell, vs. Holy Cross, at Colgate, and vs. Lafayette in The Rivalry. Can they do it? Culture Changing: B+ .  I was there in the Bronx last week after the tough 38-35 defeat to Fordham, and there wasn't a single player emerging from the locker room that looked like they didn't care.  Every face was glum.  They didn't even seem sad.  More frustrated and angry. That may seem normal, considering the agonizing way the Mountain Hawks lost, but it was a marked chan