Skip to main content

Lehigh At Colgate Game Breakdown and Fearless Prediction: Will Lehigh Get to Where Their Feet Are?

Lehigh and Colgate is always a big game, whether both teams are going in undefeated or, as in this case, an 0-5 team is squaring off against a 2-3 team.

In a testimony to how evenly matched both of these teams have been over the years, Colgate and Lehigh have split their last 10 meetings, and no team has won more than 3 straight against the other since the inception of the Patriot League.

Colgate and Lehigh have faced off 54 times, and the overall record has been, fittingly, close, with Colgate holding a slender 29-23-2 advantage.  The last tie came in 1980, a 17-17 tie at Taylor Stadium in which Lehigh's John Whitehead and Colgate's Fred Dunlap faced off as head coach.  In a way, that hotly-contested tie sort-of epitomizes the competitiveness of this rivalry today.

Thanks to Colgate's game notes and The Colgate Maroon-News for providing key parts of this content.

Breaking Down Colgate


Writing a Colgate game breakdown and fearless prediction is personally my absolute favorite to write.  Why?  Because their offensive strategy hasn't changed that much over the last decade, from former head coach Dick Biddle to head coach Dan Hunt.

Having said that, although they execute the read option often, frequently with a tight end wide and a blocking fullback to lead the charge, and extremely athletic quarterbacks and running backs to gain yardage, they have also gained an impressive precision passing attack that means opposing defenses can't simply put nine in the box in order to give their running backs nowhere to run.

One thing that really sticks out about this season's Colgate Raiders is how young they are on offense, thanks to an overload of injuries and a decision to start a freshman quarterback.

QB Grant Breneman
Colgate fans love the potential of freshman QB Grant Breneman, a prototypical athletic, running, mistake-minimizing quarterback who bears an uncanny resemblance to former Lehigh PF Tim Kempton.  So far this season, he has 152 net rushing yards, 491 passing yards, and a grand total of 6 touchdowns scored.

One of the things Breneman has done fairly well is hang onto the football.  Against five tough opponents (Cal Poly, Furman, Richmond, Buffalo, and Cornell), he only has one interception, and as a team Colgate only has 3 lost fumbles.  But when Breneman has been forced to pass, especially on 3rd down, he hasn't been able to move the sticks consistently.

Like last season, Colgate's running back situation is interesting in the fact that there's some uncertainty as to whom is available at running back.

Last week, senior RB James Holland didn't play vs. Cornell, and there is speculation as to whether he'll be available for the game vs. Lehigh this weekend.  This was the exact same situation as last season, when Holland was banged up and ended up not going against the Mountain Hawks, much to the Raiders' detriment, in my opinion.

For the last few weeks Colgate's 1-2 rushing punch has consisted of sophomore RB Alex Matthews (303 yards on the season, and 1 TD) and freshman RB Malik Twyman (97 yards, 1 TD).  To me, they are very similar to Washington in terms of the style of back that they are, small but tough runners, but in my mind, they are not Holland.

Colgate RB James Holland
It's fair to say that with Holland in there, Colgate is a different team when it comes to getting physical, grind-it-out yards to keep the sticks moving.  Interestingly, there's also injury concerns with the back that played in his place last year, junior RB Keyon Washington, who seems like he's definitely out.

The key to preparing for the Raiders in this ares is clearly to assume that Holland is playing and will be 100% healthy for such a critical league game, despite the fact that Colgate's game notes list Matthews 1, and Twyman 2 .  Regardless of who's back there, gap discipline will be crucial against Colgate's spread-option attack.

One interesting wrinkle about Colgate's offense these days is that the don't have a fullback listed on the two-deep, and indeed only have one fullback on the roster.  That's a departure from prior seasons where the Raiders have had some greats, but it also shows a shift to a more spread-style running attack this year.

OL Ryan Paulish
One thing that has held back the Colgate offense somewhat has been the fact that no one player has emerged as a go-to threat through the air.  The closest to that role has been junior WR Owen Rockett (17 catches, 199 yards, 2 TDs) but Colgate's passing attack has been a receiver-by-committee approach this season, alternatively leaning on senior WR Alex Greenawalt (87 yards, 1 TD), junior TE Nick Martinsen (101 yards) and sophomore TE Nick Diaco (59 yards), who are also very strong downfield blockers for the running game.

The foundation of a great Colgate offense has always been a great offensive line. Guys like senior OL Ryan Paulish is a prototypical Colgate's "O" lineman that is big and physical, and they'll try to out-physical you to the victory.  Great offensive line play is the key to every Colgate victory.


Colgate plays a base 3-4 that has an all-Patriot League level defensive front that is both talented and deep.  In the Raiders' two wins this year vs. Cal Poly and Cornell, the defense has had a field day, last week registering nine sacks against the hapless Big Red.

DE Pat Afriyie
Last week, one of the best bull rushers in all of FCS, senior DE Pat Afriyie, returned to action after getting injured in the waning minutes of the Cal Poly game.  It's no coincidence that the Raiders have won both games where he's appeared -  he's a major disruptor in all aspects - speed to the quarterback, and also getting his hands up to knock down passes over the middle.

Even worse for Lehigh, he's the type of player whose mere presence opens up the possibility for other to play loose and aggressive.  Though he only had 2 tackles and 1 sack against Cornell, sophomore DE Nick Wheeler (3 sacks) was a huge beneficiary to Afriyie's extra attention on the offensive line.  Rounding out the line, 315 lb sophomore NG Cam Rohr is an effective run-stuffer - Colgate averages yielding only a little over 150 rushing yards per game.

LB Trent Williams (center)
At linebacker. senior LB Trent Williams is the anchor of the linebacking unit on the inside, who had been hurt but returned last week vs. Cornell to register 9 tackles.  Junior LB John Steffen and sophomore LB Nick Ioanilli round out the unit, while junior LB Dillon Deluliis got a start last week for the injured junior LB T.J. Holl.  Whether Holl is in there or not, this is a solid tackling defense that forced a bunch of sacks and turnovers vs. Cornell last week.

In general, Colgate's secondary has always been an aggressive bunch that does have a tendency to be boom-or-bust.  When they boom, like last week, they force interceptions, which they did three times last week.  When they bust, like they did to some degree vs. Furman, they give up scores and yardage through the air.

In Colgate's wins, the secondary has really stepped up, most notably sophomore CB Abu Daramy-Swaray, who came up big in the 4th quarter against Cal Poly in terms of pass break-ups, and junior SS Alec Wisniewski, who has an interception in three separate games this year.  Rounding out the unit is junior FS Ben Hunt (1 INT) and sophomore CB Jordan Jefferson (1 INT, 3 pass break-ups).

Special Teams

Sophomore PK Chris Puzzi has been  4-for-5 on field goal tries this season, but in general, Hunt, like Biddle before him, will only settle for the short stuff on field goals and will largely go for it in on 4th down if the alternative is a 40 yard field goal.  Puzzi's longest this season is 35 yards.

Junior P Josh Cerra continues to be a solid Patriot League punter, averaging a shade under 40 yards per boot.

Sophomore DB Abu Daramy-Swaray continues to be the primary punt and kickoff returner, a job he did very well last season as well.  Daraby-Swaray has 296 return yards on the season.

LFN's Keys to the Game

1.  Positive turnover ratio.  In order for Lehigh to win a football game, winning the turnover ratio is always a desirable outcome, but it is especially critical against Colgate where their entire gameplan is geared towards making fewer mistakes than you.  That means overall taking care of the ball and forcing turnovers, wherever they may happen.  Positive - or even - turnover ratio will go a long way towards Lehigh winning a football game.

2.  Small plays.  In order for Lehigh to win a football game, they have to prevent the Raiders from achieving big plays - big yardage plays, big kick returns, big turnover returns.  I'd rather Colgate make twenty runs resulting in a field goal than one run resulting in a 50+ yard touchdown.  Limiting them to making small plays vs. big plays will go a long way towards Lehigh winning a football game.

3. Zen And The Art of Football.  Head coach Ron Rivera of the Carolina Panthers has a sort-of mantra for his players: "be where your feet are."  It's another word for "mindfulness": staying present and having awareness in the moment, staying present without allowing internal or external elements to alter focus.   Too often this season, these coaches and players have seemed influenced by "internal or external elements."  I don't know what these are, but I do know that in order for Lehigh to win a football game, they need to "be where their feet are."  If they are - and they've done this last season - they can win this game.

Fearless Prediction

You know the game has ramifications - it always does.  You know the game will be close - it always is.   When Lehigh plays Colgate, it's a rivalry, and it sets the stage for a potentially great game this weekend - regardless of the fact that it's a 0-5 team facing off against a 2-3 team.  Letdown, on both sides, isn't an option.

For yet another week, it's an opportunity for Lehigh to "get to where their feet are" and keep their goal of winning a football game alive.  For five weeks, the Mountain Hawks' haven't gotten to where their feet are, and they've lost every time.  This is the midway point of the season, and Lehigh is running out of chances to win a football game.

If you are going by past performance, why would you pick Lehigh to win?  You wouldn't.  You'd scan the entirety of Lehigh's losses, and without much thought you'd pick Colgate to win.

But if ignition happens, if Lehigh gets to where their feet are, if the Mountain Hawks play up to their considerable potential, they certainly have a chance to turn this whole thing around.  The time is now.  There is no more runway.  Potential is disappearing, and it's becoming the won/loss record.

I choose optimism.  I choose ignition.  I choose the turnaround.  I just hope I'm making the right choice.

Lehigh 34, Colgate 26


Douglas said…
The defending PL Head Coach happens to be Andy Coen... It looks like you lifted from last year when Dan Hunt was the defending HC... Hope you are right on your pick but not sure I can agree.. Colgate is a tough place for any Lehigh team to win...

Popular posts from this blog

How The Ivy League Is Able To Break the NCAA's Scholarship Limits and Still Consider Themselves FCS

By now you've seen the results.  In 2018, the Ivy League has taken the FCS by storm. Perhaps it was Penn's 30-10 defeat of Lehigh a couple of weeks ago .  Or maybe it was Princeton's 50-9 drubbing of another team that made the FCS Playoffs last year, Monmouth.  Or maybe it was Yale's shockingly dominant 35-14 win over nationally-ranked Maine last weekend. The Ivy League has gone an astounding 12-4 so far in out-of-conference play, many of those wins coming against the Patriot League. But it's not just against the Patriot League where the Ivy League has excelled.  Every Ivy League school has at least one out-of-conference victory, which is remarkable since it is only three games into their football season.  The four losses - Rhode Island over Harvard, Holy Cross over Yale, Delaware over Cornell, and Cal Poly over Brown - were either close losses that could have gone either way or expected blowouts of teams picked to be at the bottom of the Ivy League. W

UMass 21, Lafayette 14, halftime

Are you watching this game? UMass had this game under control until about 3 minutes in the second quarter, and then got an interception, converted for a TD. Then the Leopards forced a fumble off the return, and then converted THAT for a TD, making this a game. It's on CN8. You really should be watching this.

Made-Up Midseason Grades for Lehigh Football

 We are now officially midway through the 2023 Lehigh football season.  The Mountain Hawks sit at 1-5 overall, and 0-1 in the Patriot League. I thought I'd go ahead and make up some midseason grades, and set some "fan goals" for the second half. The 2023 Mountain Hawks were picked to finish fifth in the seven team Patriot League.  In order to meet or exceed that expectation, they'll probably have to go at least 3-2 the rest of the way in conference play.  Their remaining games are vs. Georgetown, at Bucknell, vs. Holy Cross, at Colgate, and vs. Lafayette in The Rivalry. Can they do it? Culture Changing: B+ .  I was there in the Bronx last week after the tough 38-35 defeat to Fordham, and there wasn't a single player emerging from the locker room that looked like they didn't care.  Every face was glum.  They didn't even seem sad.  More frustrated and angry. That may seem normal, considering the agonizing way the Mountain Hawks lost, but it was a marked chan