Skip to main content

Lehigh at Colgate Game Breakdown and Fearless Prediction, 10/5/2019

Lehigh and Colgate is always a big game, whether both teams are going in undefeated or, as in this case, an 2-7 team is squaring off against a 8-0 team.

In a testimony to how evenly matched both of these teams have been over the years,  no team has won more than 3 straight against the other since the inception of the Patriot League.

Colgate and Lehigh have faced off 55 times, and the overall record has been, fittingly, close, with Colgate holding a slender 30-24-2 advantage.  The last tie came in 1980, a 17-17 tie at Taylor Stadium in which Lehigh's John Whitehead and Colgate's Fred Dunlap faced off as head coach.  In a way, that hotly-contested tie sort-of epitomizes the competitiveness of this rivalry today.

Last year, Colgate cruised to a 48-6 victory, one of the more lopsided in the rivalry's recent history.  This year's edition is unlikely to be a similar outcome.

Breaking Down Colgate

Writing a Colgate game breakdown and fearless prediction is personally my absolute favorite to write.  Why?  Because their offensive strategy hasn't changed that much over the last decade, from former head coach Dick Biddle to head coach Dan Hunt.

Although they execute the read option often, frequently with a tight end wide and a blocking fullback to lead the charge, and extremely athletic quarterbacks and running backs to gain yardage, they have also in the past have had an impressive precision passing attack that means opposing defenses can't simply put nine in the box in order to give their running backs nowhere to run.

It's hard to truly gauge where Colgate's offense is, in reality, because though the Raiders are 0-5 against an FBS team (Air Force); two CAA teams that are either in (Villanova) or spent time in (Maine) the Top 25; a third CAA team (William and Mary), and an Ivy League team that has gone 15-1 in their last 16 games (Dartmouth).

Making matters worse was that 6'1 200 lb QB Grant Breneman, the starter last season, had his leg in a boot after an injury early in the William and Mary game.   Against Maine and Dartmouth, it was Breneman's backup, QB Jake Froschauer, who started against Maine, and when HE got hurt, QB Noah Rothman started against Dartmouth.

Who will start on Saturday for Colgate?  We won't know until Saturday at 1:00 PM, most likely, but word has been that Breneman should be healthy in time for league play.  Lehigh is preparing as if it's going to be Breneman.

Most years the Raiders rotate through a stable of running backs, but so far this season the rushing load has been shouldered by senior RB Alex Matthews and junior RB Malik Twyman, along with the three different quarterbacks.  Unusually for Colgate, they are only averaging 100 yards rushing per game - but that might be more of a function of the Raiders' being behind so often against great competition. 

Colgate's receiving corps clearly isn't the first option on offense, but they do sport some good receiving options on offense.  6'4, 235 lb senior TE Nick Diaco is a proven threat catching the ball and scored his first touchdown two weeks ago against Maine.  5'11 sophomore WR Garret Oakey has emerged as the most reliable target of the wideouts, with 264 yards, but the Colgate offense will mix things up a lot in terms of receiving targets.

Colgate offensive line has struggled at times, but it's hard to say whether that is from their brutal schedule or injuries.  Though their O line will be one of the bigger ones Lehigh will have faced thus far, their line seems thin due to injury.  OL Jack Badovinac was on STATS' preseason all-America team.


Colgate plays a base 3-4 that has always had an all-Patriot League level defensive front that is both talented and deep.  Last year, Colgate had by any objective measure one of the best defenses in the nation.  But they have come crashing back down to earth after their 0-5 start.

Yes, DE Nick Wheeler is still an amazing talent which causes offensive coordinators fits.  Amidst Colgate's struggles, he still leads the team in tackles for loss (6) and sacks (2).  But the rest of the front seven has struggled with injury.  LB Nick Ioanilli (37 tackles) stands out in the middle on the Raider defense for sure, and LB Milton Braasch and LB J.C. Gaughan have also done solidly as well.  But as a group they haven't had success creating turnovers in the Raiders' first five games, which hasn't helped matters.

Though Colgate's defensive front has always been fearsome, it's their veteran secondary, that was exceptional last season.  Led by senior CB Abu Daramy-Swaray and sophomore CB Colin Heard, Colgate still could have the best set of shutdown corners in the league, even on an 0-5 team.  Few teams choose to pass Daramy-Swaray's way, and Heard already has 2 interceptions.  FS Aidan Gaertner and SS Jordan Jefferson round out the unit.

Special Teams

Last season, senior PK Chris Puzzi was a very good weapon for the Raiders, though this season's 2-for-4 tally doesn't really show what he can do with his leg. 

P Ben Amor is a really strong punter, averaging more than 44 yards per boot so far this season.

DB Abu Daramy-Swaray continues to be the primary punt and kickoff returner, a job he has held for four years running now.  Last season he had a 77 yard punt return for a touchdown, and he's still very effective on punts with an average of 10 yards per return.  Most teams kick away from him on kickoffs, choosing to CB William Gruber instead (who is no slouch himself, averaging more than 20 yards per return).

LFN's Keys to the Game

1.  Positive turnover ratio.  In order for Lehigh to win this football game, winning the turnover ratio is always a desirable outcome, but it is especially critical against Colgate where their entire gameplan is geared towards making fewer mistakes than you.  That means overall taking care of the ball and forcing turnovers, wherever they may happen.  Positive - or even - turnover ratio will go a long way towards Lehigh taking this game.

2.  Hit gaps.  Colgate's discipline running and passing come from creating and hitting gaps, and to stop that Lehigh needs to do a better job than the Raiders plugging gaps and tackling.  Bad tackling has doomed more than one Lehigh team vs. Colgate.  If the Mountain Hawks can continue their impressive job plugging gaps and stopping the run, I like their chances.

3. Time Of Possession.  This game won't be won on big plays, I don't think - it will be won by the team that is more patient.  For Lehigh's offense, that means continuing to plug away on offense and being patient, but also holding onto the ball longer and getting sustained drives, however they come about.  Merrimack held the ball for more than 36 minutes last week against Lehigh; if Colgate does the same thing, Lehigh will lose.

Fearless Prediction

Lehigh 19, Colgate 17


Anonymous said…
great take on the game Chuck, but what's that intro about a 2-7 vs. 8-0 team?
Anonymous said…
Naysayers, where are you???? Chuck called it.

GREAT defensive effort. Giant kudos to Coach Gilmore for turning that entire situation around. That 98 yard drive was a season changing moment. Offensive confidence just rose 300% after that drive. The OL finally coming around, creating an actual running game again.

The PL is now right there for the MHawks. Hopefully it will translate into Goodman energy the rest of the season.
Anonymous said…
Great game Lehigh! Looks like we finally found our quarterback too, fine job Monaco! Defense stood out and the OL was solid. The start we needed for PL play....let's ride the momentum.
Kepler John said…
Useful information, we at provide latest update about the sports news of the United States. We focus on the football match and games for girls also.
Read more: Games For Girls
Anonymous said…
Yes Mr Monaco your son’s completion rate was finally over 50%. 57% to be exact.

Popular posts from this blog

How To Get Lehigh Fans To Games, And Keep Them There?

You don't have to have attended more than twenty-five years of Lehigh football games to know it's a completely different world out there for your friendly neighborhood sports fan.

When Lehigh's Murray Goodman Stadium was opened in 1988, there were only about a dozen channels on the small, eighteen inch black and white TV we had in our dorm room.  Only two channels might have had "major college football" games on at the same time a Lehigh football game was being played live over the mountain.  (Notre Dame, the only school who had all their games televised, almost always played their games at 3:30 PM.)

Nowadays there's way more entertainment options on a typical college weekend than ever, and it's very logical to think that the increased amount of competition might not just keep students away from attending football games, but local fans as well.

It's not an issue confined to Lehigh - in 2014, home attendance at all FBS games dropped to their lowest le…

Fifteen Guys Who Might be Lehigh's Next Football Coach (and Five More)

If you've been following my Twitter account, you might have caught some "possibilities" as Lehigh's next head football coach like Lou Holtz, Brett Favre and Bo Pelini.  The chance that any of those three guys actually are offered and accept the Lehigh head coaching position are somewhere between zero and zero.  (The full list of my Twitter "possibilities" are all on this thread on the Lehigh Sports Forum.)

However the actual Lehigh head football coaching search is well underway, with real names and real possibilities.

I've come up with a list of fifteen possible names, some which I've heard whispered as candidates, others which might be good fits at Lehigh for a variety of reasons.

UPDATE: I have found five more names of possible head coaches that I am adding to this list below.

Who are the twenty people?  Here they are, in alphabetical order.

2018 Week 9, Bucknell: Tailgate Report, And How To Catch the Game

At Murray Goodman Stadium this weekend, two Patriot League teams will be looking for their second win and trying to end the 2018 season on a high note. 

Lehigh (1-7, 0-3 PL) takes on Bucknell (1-7, 1-2 PL) this week on "Heroes Day", where all first responders (military, fire, EMT, police) can pick up a game ticket free of charge at the Goodman Stadium Ticket Office.

If you can't make it to the game, you can catch the contest on TV on the Stadium Network via these over-the-air networks or watch the feed of that broadcast online through the Patriot League Network.  Matt Martucci, Ross Tucker and Marisa Pilla are the over-the-air broadcast team.

You can also catch the game on FOX AM 1230 and 1320, with Matt Kerr, Tom Fallon, Matt Markus and Mike Yadush on the call, with the most excellent Lehigh pregame show starting at 11:30 AM.  You can get it through your regular radio, listen to the broadcast streamed through TuneIn, or just simply going to the webpage…