Skip to main content

How Lehigh Can (Maybe) Unbreak a Broken Season

There really aren't any other words to use.  The season is currently broken.

Anyone who bravely worked their way to the game last weekend in rainy, windy Worcester, Mass had to have come to the same conclusion.

The only thing keeping 2-6 Holy Cross from breaking their previous high-water mark of 59 against the Mountain Hawks was mercy.  In the red zone late in the game, the 2018 Holy Cross Crusaders would settle on their largest-ever margin of victory against Lehigh in program history, taking a knee to win the game 56-0 instead of probably winning the game 63-0.

Things... looked... broken.

"This is an embarrassment," head coach Andy Coen rightfully said on the radio after the game.  "We didn't do anything right."

Every stat sheet passed out to the Lehigh players and coach staff ought to be put into a burn cage and set afire.

There should be a parental campus-wide internet filter preventing anyone associated with Lehigh from Googling the awful numbers from this game, which include 4 turnovers, a blocked chip-length field goal, and 203 total yards of offense.

Even P Ed Mish, with a net of 31 yards per punt, had an awful afternoon.  This is how bad it was.

I am not a football coach, but the first thing you need to do to turn around any situation that is wrong is to speak the truth about it.  The situation is broken.  Things cannot continue in this way.  I don't know what need to change, but it has to be something.

So we admit that it broken.  We don't want it to remain broken.  The only goal now is to pick up the pieces and make something of it.

How does Lehigh do that?  To investigate, we can look at two prominent FCS football programs who are both going through their own turmoil right now.

Montana Mauled by UC Davis

In Montana, things are falling apart with the Grizzlies fan base after a stunning loss to one of the top teams in the Big Sky, UC Davis.  

Up 21-3 at half, the Grizzlies had a second-half meltdown of the ages, being outscored 46-0 in the second half at home and falling to the Aggies 46-21.

Four turnovers, three of which happened in the second half, loomed large.

It was, according to The Missoulian, the worst home loss since the opening of Washington-Grizzly Stadium, which opened in 1986.

“Our guys were very, very ready to play,” Montana head coach Bobby Hauck said. “They came out and went after it, had a real zest for the game. I’m disappointed that we couldn’t sustain that the second half. When it started to go the wrong direction, we didn’t get it turned around, which was disappointing. Obviously, disappointed not to win it.”

The people over at the Montana message board were just a bit more than "disappointed", as this wasn't the first time Montana was undone by mistakes.  The Missoulian gave out grades for the game: they weren't pretty.  Reports of rabid Griz fans streaming for the exits in the 4th quarter has a number of reporters and message board folks pretty upset.

Even though it's his first year back at Montana, Hauck's seat is getting warm, fast.

Athletic director Kent Haslam, who hired Hauck in 2017 for his second tour of duty at Montana after a successful, but controversial, stint in Missoula, basically has been pretty invisible this week.  It seems like his Montana solution is to ignore the fans and pretty much do nothing.

To be fair it is Hauck's first season back, so few of the players are his - but doing nothing doesn't seem like the right course of action, either.  Something is broken in Missoula.  Something needs more than "disappointment" - it needs fixing.

We'll see how they handle it.

Bo Don't Know His Team Anymore

Courtesy Emily Matthews/Youngstown Vindicator
There's also Bo Pelini's Youngstown State Penguins, who sleepwalked to a 43-17 defeat to 4-4 Indiana State this weekend and fell to 3-5 on the season, effectively putting Youngstown State in the cellar of the Missouri Valley Conference.

Midway through the second quarter, the Penguins took a 10-7 lead, and then, suddenly, couldn't do anything right again in the entire game.  The rest of the game Youngstown State was outscored 40-7, giving up 351 yards passing to the weakest passing attack in the conference.

In the post-game pressers, a lot of frustration boiled over that had been stewing, apparently, for quite some time.

“We’re a bad football team,” said Pelini as he opened up a press conference in which he ripped every area of the football team, including himself. “Anybody is a bad football team when you take the field like we did today. I’m trying to get our guys enthused and juiced up. We’re coming out, and there wasn’t an ounce of enthusiasm. I wish I had answers for you. Never in my life have I been this disgusted.

“I don’t know how guys can take the field with no enthusiasm,” he added. “And it’s way too many guys. It’s like they don’t even like to play the sport.”

Senior DT Savon Smith agreed.

“It’s want-to,” he said after the game. “If you don’t want to win the game, you’re not going to do it. If you don’t want to beat the guy that’s lined up over you, you’re not going to do it. It’s want-to at this point. It’s Week 8. We’re tired. We had a long camp. We’re practicing all week, for weeks on end, and guys don’t want to do it. So, that’s the result.

“What’s even more frustrating is that, the leaders on this team, the seniors, we definitely try to get guys together and try to figure out what’s going on. The most frustrating thing is that guys aren’t doing their job. They’re not taking it serious.  It’s even more frustrating having the coaches look at us and say, ‘Why aren’t you doing that?’ That’s the most frustrating part. We’re really trying to get the team together and build a team, get the team to play together, and the coaches kind of look at you like, ‘Why aren’t you doing this? Why isn’t the team doing this?’ And it’s kind of your fault, but that’s the cause of being a leader. That’s the price you pay. I’m OK with that.”

Bo won't be canned this week, but it's clear from the excellent reporting by The Tribune-Chronicle that discord is mounting within the program, and if some sort of turnaround doesn't happen by the end of the season, he might not make it another season as Penguins head coach.

Something is broken in Youngstown.  It needs more than just a public airing of grievances to fix.  We'll see how they handle it.


What Montana, Youngstown State and Lehigh all have in common is one thing - a huge Rivalry game upcoming on which to focus.  In that sense, all three programs are very fortunate.

The Penguins this week face off against the No. 1 team in the nation, North Dakota State.  By definition a game like this is going to be a bowl-like atmosphere and a tremendous chance for Youngstown to really ruin the Bison season.  It will be a chance for this Penguin team to shock the world, and will be a pretty good story if they can pull it off.  It would be a tremendous story for their seniors if they can pull it off.  Upsets in the Fargodome are as rare as the steak I like to eat.

Montana always has "Cat-Griz", the battle against Montana State for Treasure State Champions.  As bad as they have played lately, Hauck can erase the disappointment of this whole season with one singular win.  Unlike Pelini and Coen, he is in his first year back as head coach, so his leash is undoubtedly longer.  But a win would turbo-charge the momentum into the offseason and would likely make recruiting - and building a national-championship team in the future - that much easier.

And Lehigh has college football's most-played Rivalry, the 154th meeting between Lehigh and Lafayette, played in a packed house during a crazy week at school and in front of a bowl-like atmosphere, this year in Easton.

Those who haven't experienced it yet are in for something unique and memorable.  Participation in this Rivalry game is an honor and a privilege, and something Fordham and Colgate coaches and players don't get to experience.  Many other football players wish they had it - these players and coaches get to make it happen.  Being a part of it is being a part of history - it's a lot more than being immortalized in a flowery post by some blogger.

It is that, the big Rivalry game that still looms, that gives a potentially broken season form and purpose.  It's what allows a 1-7 team to go out and keep grinding to try to find a way to figure things out.  There is value at Lehigh in their football team figuring things out in November that many other FCS teams don't enjoy.

So to me, unbreaking this broken season can still be done.

That doesn't mean that fixing the rift between coaches and players is going to be easy, or that Andy's seat isn't hot, or that there's an easy way to get players to want to play who don't want to play.  Fixing things like this isn't easy anywhere in the country.

What I can say is that it's going to require something different.  Doing nothing is not an option.

If there is one, singular lesson that comes out of the last three train wreck games, it's that a team and a staff not all on the same page cannot win a football game against anybody.  It's a lesson that has plenty of worth well beyond the game of football.

I don't have the magic wand to magically fix what is ailing the program right now, but I do know it requires everyone being on the same page, and working in tandem to achieve the goal of winning a football game.  Somewhere on this team there must be a place of common motivation.  It is up to this team to find that motivation and make it happen.

In order to beat Lafayette in a few weeks, a foundation needs to be set.  It can be done in the next two games.  But it requires unbreaking what's broken, and time is running out.

We'll see how this team handles it.


Anonymous said…
Lafayette is your father's rival, students couldn't care less. Andy needs to step down now, there is no salvaging this train wreck.
Anonymous said…
The largely hung-over student body doesn't line up against the Leopards. The players very much care about beating Lafayette. That will never change. And almost all of us would like to see a coaching change at season's end, but I there is really no purpose to do it now. To make it effective in any way, you would have to clean out virtually the entire staff of coordinators and position coaches, which no one is going to do. Only Andy Coen can guide this ship around at this point. Its his time to redeem himself.
Anonymous said…
Players are largely dismissive of the Lafayette game...on both sides. Penn, Princeton, Villanova, Delaware, those are the type games that we care about most.
Anonymous said…
Fake news. ^^^
Anonymous said…
11:37PM = TROLL.

No actual player in Lehigh or Lafayette history has largely dismmissed The Rivalry.
Anonymous said…
The Rivalry...LOL
Anonymous said…
Yeah of course Penn is a much bigger rival :).. LOL.
Anonymous said…
Am requesting a short breakdown and your patented Fearless Prediction on the Princeton-Dartmouth matchup this weekend over in NJ. I am calling this rivalry and game- The Big One.

Anonymous said…
Who cares about Youngstown State, UC Davis, or Montana? All I care about is Lehigh, and I am embarrassed,frustrated,and angry about how bad the team is. Except for a few talented offensive players, it was really quite bad last year. The team won the Patriot League only because the league was so weak. Andy seems shell shocked, and mumbles through his interviews. The quality of the players has deteriorated significantly despite the awarding of scholarships. Probably a good time to clean house at the end of the season.
Anonymous said…
Chuck, EXCELLENT story on Princeton Dartmouth on GSJ today. Thanks. Its a piece that deserves to be picked up all over social media and the big websites tonight.. Wish I was going to the game. A rare sellout?

Popular posts from this blog

How To Get Lehigh Fans To Games, And Keep Them There?

You don't have to have attended more than twenty-five years of Lehigh football games to know it's a completely different world out there for your friendly neighborhood sports fan.

When Lehigh's Murray Goodman Stadium was opened in 1988, there were only about a dozen channels on the small, eighteen inch black and white TV we had in our dorm room.  Only two channels might have had "major college football" games on at the same time a Lehigh football game was being played live over the mountain.  (Notre Dame, the only school who had all their games televised, almost always played their games at 3:30 PM.)

Nowadays there's way more entertainment options on a typical college weekend than ever, and it's very logical to think that the increased amount of competition might not just keep students away from attending football games, but local fans as well.

It's not an issue confined to Lehigh - in 2014, home attendance at all FBS games dropped to their lowest le…

Fifteen Guys Who Might be Lehigh's Next Football Coach (and Five More)

If you've been following my Twitter account, you might have caught some "possibilities" as Lehigh's next head football coach like Lou Holtz, Brett Favre and Bo Pelini.  The chance that any of those three guys actually are offered and accept the Lehigh head coaching position are somewhere between zero and zero.  (The full list of my Twitter "possibilities" are all on this thread on the Lehigh Sports Forum.)

However the actual Lehigh head football coaching search is well underway, with real names and real possibilities.

I've come up with a list of fifteen possible names, some which I've heard whispered as candidates, others which might be good fits at Lehigh for a variety of reasons.

UPDATE: I have found five more names of possible head coaches that I am adding to this list below.

Who are the twenty people?  Here they are, in alphabetical order.

Friday Water Cooler: Emma Watson, And Harvard Football

(Photo courtesy

I'm sure this won't be appreciated by the latest famous freshman to attend an Ivy League school. No, no, I'm not talking about Brooke Shields, I'm talking about Emma Watson, the actress who is best known for her turn as Hermione Granger in the Harry Potter movies.

We always knew there was something, well, different about kids who went to Harvard - a bit of an upturned nose, perhaps, annoying arrogance, or maybe even some Brahmin-ness while we're at it. Turns out, though, that some students were up to something more sinister: stalking Ms. Brown University at the Harvard/Brown game last weekend, as reported by the New York Post:

Page Six reported on Tuesday that the "Harry Potter" starlet and Brown University freshman looked "quite shaken" on Saturday as Harvard beat Brown 24-21 in Cambridge. Watson was reportedly flanked by security guards to protect her from gawkers. But her discomfort was actually the result of a t…